Pakistan’s current crisis and India’s train of thought


 

After the 1970 general elections, Indira Gandhi exploited the civil war in East Pakistan to dismember and, according to the Indian defence analyst K. Subhramanyam "Kick Pakistan out of South East Asia". No one denies that Mujib and his Awami League supporters played into India’s hands. The separatist tendency in East Pakistan found open expression and was translated by the Bengali intelligentsia into a popular movement, abetted strongly by India. That the West Pakistani centers of power, particularly the Punjabi and Sindh feudal class, had also gravitated towards separating the two wings, is generally ignored. Some West Pakistani politicians, particularly the Punjabi feudal Mumtaz Daultana, advertently or inadvertently glorified Mujib and refused to attend Ayub Khan's Roundtable conference unless Mujib, imprisoned on treason charges in the Agartala conspiracy, was released from prison. Half a century later Mujib's daughter Hasina Wajid declared that Agartala Conspiracy was real.

In 1971, if Pakistan’s military leadership were serious about East Pakistan, it would have pre-empted India before the Indian Army had fully mobilized and the Himalayan passes had not become snowbound. It could have done this by attacking India in May or September 1971 in the Ravi-Chenab Corridor. The area between Samba and Dera Baba Nanak was initially held by a division and presented to Pakistan the weakest gap in the Indian defences for launching a pre-emptive attack. Located in the hinterland, 1 Corps was to assume responsibility in this sector on arrival (Amin, 1999; Katoch, 2011). 

 Lt General Gul Hasan Khan, and Air Marshal Rahim Khan, during their visit to Beijing in November 1970, had convinced themselves (Under Bhutto's influence) that East Pakistan was doomed and Pakistan Army would not be able to withstand the Indian Army onslaught once an all-out war started. Having convinced themselves about the hopelessness of the situation,  they decided that when the ill-fated eastern wing collapsed, they would coerce  Yahya into stepping down in favor of a civilian setup that protected their interests - Bhutto will become the ruler, Gul Hasan Army Chief, and Rahim Khan to remain Air Chief (Khan,2008). Had it not been for Bhutto and some of his booze companions, Yahya among them,  India could not succeed in hacking away East Pakistan and turning it into Bangladesh.  

In the present circumstances, what is the train of thought of the Indian civil and military leadership?

To have some idea, we go back to the 1971 War. In her official statement in the Indian parliament after the fall of Dhaka, Indira Gandhi made a fleeting reference to "human rights abuses in Balochistan”, implicitly threatening Indian covert and overt interference in the troubled province (this has since been dubbed out from the official records but can be verified from All India Radio transcripts). The Soviet leadership had also warned Bhutto that if a Bangladesh-like situation emerged again, the Soviet Union would act exactly as it did during the 1971 War.

 At midnight, 9 February 1973, Bhutto’s government claimed to have intercepted weapons shipments smuggled from The Soviet Union with Iraqi assistance. The next day a team of Special Services Group and Rangers stormed the Iraqi embassy and found a cache of Soviet arms and ammunition along with a large amount of money that was to be distributed among Baloch separatist groups. Bhutto asserted that the arms and money were intended to provide military and financial aid to Baloch nationalists fighting against Pakistan and Iran (then ruled by the Shah of Iran). 

 The London Club, during the 1970s, was a group of scions of mostly Punjabi and Sindhi elite studying in London. There were twenty-five members of the group studying London.  Bored of living a life of luxury, and smitten by the ghost of Che Guevara, they left their studies and joined the Balochistan Liberation Army (BLA). Ironically, when they joined BLA, they elected to fight against the despotic rule of Bhutto, a person whom they now, especially Najam Sethi,  adore as their hero. 

Who were they? Malik Asad Rehman, son of late Justice S.A. Rahman,  who had retired as Chief Justice of Pakistan’s Supreme Court in 1968 (He was also the chairman of the Agartala Tribunal, which was trying Mujib and his accomplices in Dhaka) . Asad was one of the members of the Club. Born in Murree in 1950, Asad was schooled at Lahore’s elite educational institutions. In 1969, he left for London to study architecture. Asad did not finish his studies in London because, in 1971, he came back to Pakistan (straight to Balochistan).   Asad Rehman claims to have killed many security personnel himself. Yet at the end of the insurgency, all of them except one  Dilip Das, who was killed during the fighting,  were living, and some of them like, Najam Sethi, are still living unscathed under the very nose of the law. 

Asad Rehman, the ideologue in the group, had this to say during an interview:

1.     The London Club was actively involved in attacking Pakistan Army.

2.       Mir Hazar Khan Marri, the head of the Marri (Bijarani) tribe, provided them with rations, and purchased weapons for the resistance movement, from Afghanistan.

3.     They also snatched weapons and ammunition from Pakistan Army.

 In 1970, when there was no insurgency in Balochistan, who sent the likes of Najam Sethi and his fellow members of the London Club to Balochistan? 

For Pakistan, the point to note is, if India, in connivance with Iran and US, is using its intelligence agencies to foment trouble in Karachi, Balochistan, and elsewhere in Pakistan, it cannot succeed without the connivance of powerful lobbies within the country. India is financing and arming the terrorists, but the bombers, the hit men, and the target killers are Pakistanis. The present politico-economic turmoil in Pakistan provides breeding grounds for centrifugal forces, particularly in the restive Balochistan province. Presently, Balochistan is ripe for foreign intervention.


         Saleem Akhtar Malik

7 May 2023


The author is a Pakistan Army veteran who regularly writes on national and international affairs, defence, military history, and military technology. His talks on these subjects are aired on his YouTube Channel "The Observation Post". His blog "Sam1953.blogspot.com" features his articles. Tweets @saleemakhtar53. 

 

 

 

 

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

The Civil-Military Divide in Pakistan in the wake of Pandora Leaks

The Indian Soldiers didn’t Lay Down their Lives for Israel

Black Magic and Witchcraft in the Islamic Republic